Confidence & Mindset
Immunity to Change: why you still don’t speak up
A four-column map from Harvard that shows why willpower isn’t the problem, and what to do instead.
You know you should speak up more in meetings. You’ve read the tips. You’ve promised yourself “next time”. And next time, you sit there with a good point in your head while the moment passes.
If that sounds familiar, you don’t lack willpower or knowledge. According to Harvard researchers Robert Kegan and Lisa Laskow Lahey, you probably have an immunity to change.
Their book Immunity to Change (2009) is one of the most useful tools we know for the confidence side of public speaking. Here’s the idea, and how to use it.
01The big idea: one foot on the brake
Your body’s immune system protects you from threats. Kegan and Lahey argue the mind has something similar. When you try to change, a hidden part of you works just as hard to keep things the same, because it believes the change is risky.
It’s like driving with one foot on the accelerator and one on the brake. You’re genuinely committed to speaking up. But you’re also committed, without realising it, to something that speaking up threatens. The brake usually wins.
The way out isn’t pushing harder on the accelerator. It’s finding the brake. Kegan and Lahey do that with a simple four-column “immunity map”.
02Column 1: Your improvement goal
Start with one goal that really matters to you, phrased as something you want to get better at. Make it specific to speaking:
- “Speak up early in leadership meetings.”
- “Present to the board without reading my slides.”
- “Put my hand up for the client pitch.”
Pick one. The map works best on a single, important goal.
03Column 2: What you do (or don’t do) instead
Now list everything you actually do that works against the goal. Be honest; this is just for you. Write behaviours, not feelings:
- I wait for others to speak first.
- I over-prepare and still don’t use it.
- I add disclaimers like “this might be a silly question”.
- I let a colleague present the work we did together.
Resist the urge to fix these. They aren’t the problem. They’re clues.
04Column 3: The worry box and your hidden commitment
This is where it gets interesting. Look at your Column 2 list and imagine doing the opposite: speaking first, with no disclaimer, in front of the most senior person in the room. Notice what you feel. Write it down. Kegan and Lahey call this the worry box.
Then turn each worry into a commitment. If you worry about looking stupid, you’re also committed to never looking stupid. That’s your hidden competing commitment, and it explains everything in Column 2 perfectly. Staying quiet isn’t a failure; it’s a very effective way to protect yourself.
05Column 4: The big assumption
Finally, ask what you must believe for that hidden commitment to feel necessary. Try an “if…, then…” sentence:
“If I say something imperfect, senior people will decide I don’t deserve my role.”
That’s your big assumption. It feels like a fact, but it’s really a belief you’ve never tested. You’ll know you’ve found it when you get a little jolt of recognition: oh, that’s why I’m stuck. Here’s what a full map can look like:
1Improvement goal
I want to speak up early and confidently in leadership meetings.
2What I do instead
Wait until others have spoken. Over‑prepare. Soften my points with “this might be wrong, but…”. Stay quiet if I’m not 100% sure.
3Hidden commitment
Worry: looking stupid in front of senior people.I’m committed to never looking unprepared or wrong in front of leaders.
4Big assumption
If I say something imperfect, they’ll decide I don’t deserve my role, and that impression will stick.
06Test the assumption with small experiments
You don’t argue yourself out of a big assumption. You gather evidence. Kegan and Lahey suggest tests that are safe and modest, that you can run soon, and that you treat as research rather than a performance. For speaking, that could be:
- Make one short point in the first ten minutes of your next team meeting.
- Drop the disclaimer once and say your point plainly.
- Ask a trusted colleague afterwards how it came across.
Then look honestly at the results. Did anyone decide you didn’t deserve your job? Usually the reaction is neutral or positive, and each experiment loosens the assumption a little. As it loosens, the behaviours in Column 2 fade on their own. That’s the shift from forcing confidence to actually having it.
Why this works so well with practice
The immunity map gives you the why. Practice gives you the evidence. That’s why we combine mindset work like this with real speaking reps and feedback, spread over 30, 60 or 90 days rather than a one-day course. Every session is another safe experiment against your big assumption.
The problem usually isn’t willpower. It’s a belief you’ve never tested.
If you’re working on speaking up, our 1:1 coaching is the best place to map and test your own assumptions with a coach. For teams, we build the same approach into our corporate training. And if pre-speech nerves are part of the picture, pair this with the Chimp Paradox.
Frequently asked questions
What is Immunity to Change?
Immunity to Change is a model and book by Harvard’s Robert Kegan and Lisa Laskow Lahey (2009). It explains why people struggle to change even when they want to: hidden competing commitments and untested “big assumptions” act like an immune system that resists change.
What are the four columns of the immunity map?
Column 1 is your improvement goal. Column 2 lists what you do or don’t do instead. Column 3 holds your worries and the hidden commitments they reveal. Column 4 is the big assumption that makes those commitments feel necessary.
How can Immunity to Change help me speak up in meetings?
It helps you find the hidden belief that keeps you quiet, such as “if I’m wrong, people will think less of me”. You then test that belief with small, safe experiments, like making one short point early in a meeting, until the evidence changes how you feel.
What is a big assumption?
A big assumption is a belief you hold as true about yourself or the world that makes your hidden commitment feel necessary. It usually hasn’t been tested. Once you test it and find it isn’t fully true, the behaviours holding you back become much easier to change.
Ready to start speaking up?
Map your own immunity to change with a coach, and build the evidence to back it up.